Is it True or Can We Lie?

1896 razorbacks

The 1896 Razorbacks. No? This photo was presented to me that way. A good look reveals very young boys and what looks like it might be a girl. Or could it be true? It would take some complicated research to find out. Want to give it a try?

Have you ever wondered where a writer obtains historical information or interviews? I began writing regional history long before the advent of the Internet as a feature writer for a weekly newspaper. Searching for the same facts today is much easier if we’re computer literate. Yet nothing beats contact with the people who have stories to share. Have you ever read a book where the author just makes everything up including facts? Whether writing fiction or nonfiction, make sure what needs to be true really is. In fiction as well as nonfiction, history, language, clothing, living conditions and so much more must be true. So I urge all writers to do their research.

Someone told me she only wanted to write contemporary stories so she wouldn’t have to do research. WRONG. Where does her hero/heroine work? In what city? Who do they deal with? What’s going on in the world around them? Good grief, check it out. Make your story ring true, make it real. Our story can be fiction, but unless you’re writing fantasy or making up urban worlds, what happens around our characters must be true or at least possible.

Fiction and nonfiction run parallel with each other in so many ways. During the twenty years I wrote for newspapers, I must have interviewed hundreds of people. My main interest soon became the history of the area where I lived and worked. The editor gave me a page where I began an historical column which I’ve written in one form or another for all those years. So I must modestly say that I’ve gotten pretty good at getting information out of people.

The first thing I learned was to write stories about the people who lived our history. It’s pretty easy to look up a bunch of facts, dates and place names and the like and put them down. Not so easy to tell the stories that will keep your readers coming back for more. So once a writer hears or reads about a specific happening, the next step is to find someone whose family history includes stories of that event. Take the lady who, when we talked about the Battle of Prairie Grove during the Civil War here in Arkansas, immediately remembered that her great-grandmother had told a story of how, from where they lived, gun fire sounded just like popcorn popping. She also told of a man who lived in a cave to keep from having to serve in the war, so he could care for his family who lived in a cabin nearby. Such stories lend color to any tale about that battle.

For years I saved tons of interviews in the hopes the stories could one day be put into a book. And when that day finally came I learned that having those stories simply wasn’t enough. I had to revisit all the places where my stories took place. Ten to twenty years can bring about a lot of change. So one entire summer my husband and I drove through four surrounding counties taking photographs that could be compared with old pictures we had and talking to folks in all the small settlements. I wanted some new stories that had never been published in any form. I wanted reality to ring true. I want the same thing in my historical and contemporary novels as well. They may have stories I dream up, but they are set in a time frame that must be spot on to keep the reader intrigued.

The worst thing you as a writer can do is publish something that isn’t ready to be published. Please, please, let a good editor read your book and take his or her advice. Or better yet, sit down and write another book, then another, until by practice you become the best writer you can be. Or quit writing now if you’re not willing to hone your craft.

Writing is a profession, and as such cannot be learned overnight. No one can teach you to be creative, but those of us who have a lot of experience in the trenches can help you learn the mechanics of turning that creativity into a well written book.

If you think good writers became good overnight, then you aren’t thinking straight. Or, go ahead and publish your book because you can do it in today’s market, but it could be the last one you publish if you don’t take the advice of well-published authors who know what they’re talking about. Study hard and long and write, write, write.

One piece of advice I give novice writers who truly want to be the best they can be is, go buy a copy of Techniques of the Selling Writer by Dwight Swain and study it like you would study for a Master’s Degree. Do the exercises and pay attention to what this fabulous writing teacher has to say. If you are going to become a good writer, then Swain can get you there if anyone can. If you aren’t willing to work toward a successful career as a writer, then get a good day job you’ll enjoy.

Were you able to check out the photo I posted? Let me know what you learn. And here’s a hint. Don’t trust Wikipedia. There’s so much wrong information there.




About veldabrotherton

For thirty years I've been a writer. Publication of my work began in 1994 . I'm pleased to have recently settled with Oghma Creative Media as my publisher. My brand is SexyDarkGritty and that applies to my western historical romances, mysteries, women's fiction and horror novels. I recently signed a contract to write westerns again, and what fun it's been working on the first one. If I weren't writing my life wouldn't be so exciting.
This entry was posted in writing and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Is it True or Can We Lie?

  1. Julie James says:

    Always in awe of everything you write and share. I will be purchasing a copy of Dwight Swain’s book, and, of course, always listening to you!

  2. Dear Miss Velda:
    I will never forget your reccommending Dwight V. Swain to me as the man who could tell me how to write. Thank you!
    I’m writting a new book now and it is going to be a doosey. I was up to fifty five thousand words and dreamed I didn’t like it. I dumped the entire story the next morning. Since then I have only dumped another twenty thousand words. It’s getting right or Write now. I’m up to fourteen thousand and just getting warmed up. I’m having a book signing this week end with a new book I wrote concerning my home town. I’ve got two of the people who grew up there with me to confirm the circumstances and they are going to be there to sign with me. The title is ‘Flight of the Fugitive.’
    Keep working on us, we’ll all start writing better.
    James M. Copeland

  3. cjfosdick says:

    I agree 110% with all you’ve said in this blog. I have always loved history and the stories behind the facts are sometimes more unbelievable than any fiction. We’ve seen a glut of writers publish stuff that is mediocre at best in the last few years. The research always shows, and quick readers will always pick up on the lazy lies. I’m curious about the picture you included. What IS the story there?

    P.S. I am hoping the cover of my first novel with WRP will be done by Debbie Taylor. I believe she did Rowena’s Hellion. I like her work and her revealing interviews. Did you request her or was she assigned to your book?

    • CJ, in reply to your question about the photo, I never found out the story, but was hesitant to ever use it as a Razorback football team, even so long ago as it was dated. Now that I’ve resurrected it for this blog, I’m going to look into it further. Will post results if I ever get any.
      As to Debbie Taylor, she was assigned to my book, but I believe you can request her. She did Wilda’s Outlaw as well, which is the first in this series.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s